| 1984 |
Kevin Cox, Fullback, First team |
| 1986 |
Terry Lovell, Midfielder, First team |
| 1987 |
Denis Hamlett, Fullback, First team |
|
David Cresswell, Midfielder, Second team |
| 1988 |
Chris George, Forward, First team |
|
John Pinter, Goalkeeper, Second team |
| 1989 |
Chris George, Forward, First team |
| 1990 |
John Pinter, Goalkeeper, First team |
|
Chris George, Forward, Second team |
| 1991 |
Greg Diamond, Midfielder, Second team |
| 1992 |
Paul Cairney, Fullback, Second team |
| 1993 |
Bucky Corban, Forward, First team |
|
Steve Kozovski, Fullback, Second team |
|
Paul Cairney, Fullback, Second team |
| 1994 |
Nildo Schubert, Forward, Second team |
| 1995 |
Nildo Schubert, Forward, Second team |
| 1996 |
Nildo Schubert, Forward, Second team |
| 1997 |
Jean Kotze, Fullback, Second team |
| 1998 |
Jean Kotze, Fullback, Second team |
|
Derek Ford, Midfielder, Second team |
| 1999 |
Jean Kotze, Midfielder, Second team |
| 2001 |
Tommy Miller, Midfielder, Second team |
| 2002 |
Nick Acosta, Forward, Second team & Co-Rookie-of-the-Year |
| 2003 |
Brad Knighton, Goalkeeper, Second team |
| 2004 |
Russell Bienias, Defender, First team |
|
Bret Patterson All-Rookie |
| 2005 |
Sam Leger, Forward, Second team |
|
Chris Murray, Midfielder, Second team |
| 2006 |
Brad Knighton, Goalkeeper, First team |
|
Chris Murray, Midfielder, Second team |
|
Pedro Pereira, Midfielder, All-Rookie |
| 2007 |
Daniel Roberts, Midfielder, All-Rookie |
|
Allen Lomax, Forward, All-Rookie |
| 2008 |
Devan Carroll, Forward, First team & CAA Player-of-the-Year |
|
Indy Smith, Defender, First team & CAA Defender-of-the-Year |
|
Brian Harrison, Midfielder, All-Rookie |
| 2009 |
Indy Smith, Defender, First team |
|
David Acosta, Defender, Second team |
|
Brock Duckworth, goalkeeper, second Team |
|
Daniel Roberts, midfield, third team |
|
Etienne Boulanger, midfield, All-Rookie |
| 2010 |
Indy Smith, Defender, First team |
|
Etienne Boulanger, midfield, third team |
|
Brock Duckworth, goalkeeper, third team |
| 2011 |
Brandon Miller, goalkeeper, first team |
|
Daniel Roberts, midfield, second team |
| 2012 |
Jamie Dell, midfield, first team |
|
Colin Bonner, Forward, All-Rookie |
| 2013 |
Jacob VanCompernolle, defender, first team |
|
Colin Bonner, forward, second team |
|
David Sizemore, midfield, second team |
|
Kellen Foster, midfield, All-Rookie |
| 2014 |
Colin Bonner, Forward, first team |
|
Jamie Dell, midfield, first team |
|
Jacob VanCompernolle, defender, first team & CAA Defensive player-of-the-Year |
|
David Sizemore, midfielder, second team |
|
Mark Harris, defender, third team |
| 2015 |
Colin Bonner, Forward, first team & All-Academic |
|
Ben Fisher, Midfielder, second team & CAA Co-Rookie of the Year |
|
Jose Garcia, Midfielder, second team |
|
Michael Mecham, Defender, second team |
| 2016 |
Julio Moncada, Forward, first team & All-Academic |
|
Joel Bylander, Midfielder, second team |
|
Mark Lindstrom, Defender, second team & All-Rookie |
|
Ryan Cretens, Goalkeeper, second team |
|
Huntley Munn, Defender, third team |
|
Phillip Goodrum, Midfielder, All-Rookie |
| 2017 |
Phillip Goodrum, Forward, first team |
|
Hjalmar Ekdal, Defender, first team, All-Rookie & Rookie-of-the-Year |
|
Ben Fisher, Midfielder, second team |
|
Joel Bylander, Midfielder, second team |
|
Kalvin Kromer, Midfielder, second team |
|
Mark Lindstrom, Defender, second team |
|
Emil Elveroth, Forward, third team & All-Rookie |
| 2022 |
Bachir Ndiaye, Midfielder, First Team |
|
Gabriel Perrotta, Goalkeeper, First Team |
|
Jalen Anderson, Forward, Second Team |
|
Josef Hefele, Defender, Second Team |
|
Gabe Mercer, Midfielder, Third Team |
|
Jake Shannon, Defender, Third Team & All-Rookie |
|
Ethan Newsome, Midfielder/Forward, All-Rookie |
| 2023 |
Pep Casas, Midfielder, Second Team |
|
Gabe Mercer, Midfielder, Third Team |
|
Jake Shannon, Defender, Third Team |
| 2024 |
Josef Hefele, Defender, Third Team |
|
Jake Shannon, Defender, Third Team |
|
Osei Gyamfi, Forward, All-Rookie |
